Real Estate Partition in California: Co-Ownership Challenges When the Levee Breaks
August 28th, 2023
Contributor: Mark B. Chernev
There is no doubt that California is a state known for its booming real property market. With the vast amount of properties and owners, real estate ownership in California can sometimes lead to complex situations when multiple owners co-own the same property. In such cases, disputes can arise over the management, use, and disposition of the property. To address these conflicts, the legal concept of "real estate partition" comes into play, providing a mechanism for co-owners to divide or sell the property fairly and equitably.
Real estate partition is the legal process through which co-owners of a property, whether it's a house, a commercial building, or vacant land, can seek a division of the property's ownership interests or the sale of the property itself. This process becomes essential when co-owners are unable to reach a consensus on how to manage or utilize the property, leading to disputes that can hinder or devalue the property’s best or most productive use.
In California, the right to partition is codified under the Code of Civil Procedure §§ 872.210-872.910. This law empowers any co-owners to file a partition lawsuit that triggers a court-supervised process that seeks to resolve the disagreement. In most cases any owner has an absolute right to partition. There are two main types of partition available in California: partition in kind and partition by sale.
- Partition in Kind: Also known as a physical division, partition in kind involves the physical separation of the property into distinct portions, with each co-owner receiving ownership of a specific portion. This method is commonly used when the property can be easily divided without causing significant loss in value. For example, a large piece of land could be divided into separate parcels, each owned individually.
- Partition by Sale: When the property cannot be easily divided, or if the co-owners prefer to cash out their interests, partition by sale is pursued. In this scenario, the court orders the property to be sold, and the proceeds are distributed among the co-owners according to their ownership interests. This type of partition is often chosen when the property's value is best realized through a sale, such as with a valuable commercial property or a single-family home with sentimental value. Partition by sale is also used where a property cannot be equally divided, such as dividing a single-family home or condominium.
The partition process in California involves several steps:
- Filing the Petition: One or more co-owners initiate the process by filing a partition lawsuit in the appropriate court. The lawsuit names all co-owners as parties to the case and any individual or entity that may have an interest in the property.
- Notification and Response: All co-owners and interested parties are served with legal notice of the partition lawsuit. They each have the opportunity to respond to the lawsuit and present their arguments, such as disputing the partition, or the method sought.
- Property Valuation: If the co-owners opt for partition by sale, the court will assess the value of the property through appraisals or other methods to determine a fair sale price.
- Sale or Division: Depending on the chosen method, the court will either order the sale of the property or its physical division.
- Distribution of Proceeds: In a partition by sale, once the property is sold, the proceeds are distributed among the co-owners according to their ownership interests. Any outstanding debts related to the property's sale are settled at this stage.
- Legal Fees and Costs: The expenses incurred during the partition process, such as legal fees and court costs, are generally paid from the proceeds before distribution to co-owners.
It's important to note that while real estate partition is a legally available remedy, it can be a lengthy and emotionally charged process. The court's involvement can lead to increased costs and potential strain on relationships among co-owners. Therefore, it's advisable for co-owners to consider alternative methods of resolving their disputes, such as mediation or negotiation, before pursuing a partition lawsuit.
Real estate partition in California serves as a mechanism for co-owners to address disputes over property ownership. Whether through a physical division or a sale, the partition process aims to provide a fair solution that enables co-owners to move forward while realizing the value of their investments. However, it's crucial for individuals involved in co-ownership disputes to consult with legal professionals and attorneys who specialize in real estate law to fully understand their rights, obligations, and the potential outcomes of pursuing a partition. California real estate partition information provided by San Francisco Real Estate attorney Mark Chernev. Contact us at your convenience to request a consultation.
Neither this website nor this post are intended to create an attorney-client relationship.
Categories: Real Estate Litigation